Now Reading
BITE INTO OUR FAVORITES OF BRADENTON’S NEWEST RESTAURANTS

BITE INTO OUR FAVORITES OF BRADENTON’S NEWEST RESTAURANTS

By Kelly Stilwell

Gastronomes, rejoice! New restaurants are opening all over the Bradenton area.
From Italian to sushi to new brewpubs, it’s nice to have so many delicious places
close to home! We’ve eaten at every spot on this list (sometimes more than once!),
and we can tell you wholeheartedly — you’re going to love the food!

enRich Bistro

With deep roots in Bradenton, EnRich Bistro is not necessarily new to the area. The very popular Bradenton restaurant had to make the hard decision to close during the pandemic, like many others. Unfortunately, most of those that closed did not reopen. But EnRich had a fan base hopeful for a return and, thankfully, they got their wish. EnRich reopened on Friday, May 10, and just two days later, served a crowd of 400 on Mother’s Day.

The new EnRich Bistro has modern look, with a bar area, two partially separated dining rooms, as well as a private dining area with doors that slide closed.

The Geraldson’s Farm Eggplant on the specials menu was the perfect starter; crispy fried panko eggplant was served on top of a base of herbed Chèvre and red wine reduction, with a dollop of jalapeño tomato jam. After hearing about the small plate tuna poke, I had to try it, too. The yellowfin tuna was fresh and flavorful and paired well with the avocado and wasabi kale slaw. Wonton chips were served on the side for scooping up all that deliciousness.

For entreés, we had to try the grilled Australian rack of lamb topped with smoked baba ganoush — an eggplant based creamy dip — served with a vegetable salad. I had a hard time deciding what to order for my entrée, but when EnRich owner Rich Knowles suggested I try the black garlic-crusted skirt steak, it was an easy yes. Cooked perfectly, the tender sliced beef was served with a smoked poblano chimichurri sauce and paired with delicious plantain saffron rice.

You absolutely can’t leave without trying the carrot cake,
which was the best I’ve ever eaten. The Thai basil ice cream with pistachio streusel was also amazing.
The portions at EnRich are generous, so box up your
leftovers for the next day’s lunch. We did!

You’ll find EnRich at 5239 Manatee Avenue West.
Make reservations online at enrichbistro.com
or call (941) 289-1299

Taverna Toscana

The first of three Italian restaurants on our list, the excitement for Taverna Toscana was building for some time before they finally opened on Manatee Avenue. What sets this restaurant apart of the other Italian spots is that it offers more of a rustic Italian menu than the traditional dishes you’d expect. The menu has a wide variety of options for appetizers as well as entrées.

This is definitely the kind of spot where you could sit at the bar with a glass of wine or cocktail and share a few appetizers for a meal. I’ve been to Taverna Toscana three times and enjoyed a different experience each time. The first time I shared the crostini del giorno, Fabio’s Wagyu meatball, and the grilled octopus at the bar along with a French I-75, one of their specialty craft cocktails.

On the second visit, I was with a group, and we ordered several appetizers and several entrées served family-style. Being able to taste a lot of different dishes is a great way to experience a new restaurant, so you can pick your favorite to order the next time you go. I did just that, ordering the wagyu short rib Bolognese on my last visit.

The restaurant has only been open for a couple of months and very cleverly teased the opening for 10 months with amazing photos of their mouthwatering dishes, so it’s not surprising there is a crowd every night. Make a reservation if you want to be sure to get a table.

Tavera Toscana | 1301 6th Ave W, in Bradenton. Make reservations online: tavernatoscana.com

Oyster River

Oyster River, the rooftop restaurant at the fabulous Palmetto Marriott Resort & Spa, opened at the end of July. The resort is beautiful and is only just getting started. A private beach area, spa, and more are on the way. But Oyster River is open and already often seeing crowds at their upscale fresh seafood restaurant with a Mediterranean twist. Executive chef Anthony Castro has been at the helm of restaurants all over the world, including the Shangri-La Hotel in Asia.

The menu offers quite a few choices. As you’d expect with a restaurant specializing in fresh seafood, there’s a raw bar with oysters, caviar, shrimp cocktail, and a seafood tower. We have to suggest the caviar dip with homemade chips. It’s big enough to share. Don’t miss the crab cake,
which is saying a lot from this transplanted Marylander. The burrata salad is more of an app than a salad. The presentation is beautiful, so if you’re a foodie, get your video ready. The Caesar salad was wonderful, topped with fried oysters and a parmesan wheel. The lobster bisque is creamy with pieces of fresh lobster and perfectly seasoned. For entrées, the wagyu filet comes with prawns, a crab cake, or a lobster tail. The desserts are also creative and decadent so, at minimum, choose one and share. The crème brûlée was heavenly.

The weather should be perfect now to dine on the open-air terrace with views of the Sunshine Skyway Bridge and Manatee River. Note: Oyster River Rooftop is reservation only. We’d suggest reserving well in advance.
You’ll find Oyster River Rooftop at 600 US-41, in the Palmetto Marriott Resort & Spa, near the convention center.

Inner Compass Brewing

We kept hearing about Inner Compass Brewing from friends who had visited. We finally stopped in on our way home from SRQ and found it to be a fun, family owned, neighborhood spot with a long bar and family-friendly vibe. It’s much larger inside than I expected, with 2,500 square feet of taproom, 2,500 square feet of brewery, and even more space for private events. There’s also an outside patio with more seating and an area for entertainment.

The list of beers is long, but you can taste anything on draft to find what you
like. With 30 taps, you’ll have a lot of choices. They try to have as many of their own beers on tap as they can, and any guest beers will be from our state. We loved the Stouts Honor and the Kan-Do Kölsch. Though they don’t have a full bar, they do offer a selection of wines, mimosas, High Noon vodka and tequila canned cocktails, and soft drinks.

Let’s face it, for the most part, you go to a brewery for beer, not food, but Inner Compass surprised us. We started with the fish dip, and though I have to say the housemade chips wouldn’t be my first choice to go with it, the dip was surprisingly good. We also got an order of six wings, and they were tender and juicy with just enough Buffalo sauce. Other options are teriyaki or garlic. The ICB Burger was cooked perfectly, topped with lettuce, tomato, and a pickle on a brioche bun. Other handheld options include a fried chicken sandwich, fish and chips, Philly cheesesteak, and more. There’s even a vegetarian option as well as a few salads on the menu. The pizzas looked good, too. We’ll be back.

Inner Compass Brewing is located at 10316 Technology Terrace in Bradenton.


Bar Italia

If you’re wondering why there are so many new Italian restaurants in our area, perhaps it’s because Italian food is the most popular of all ethnic cuisines, according to a 2023 article in Forbes. Bar Italia opened in July in Lakewood Ranch and hasn’t slowed since. With a lively bar, popular happy hour, and delicious food, this Italian bistro should be added to your list. As the website says, the setting is elegant, comfortable, and unpretentious. We couldn’t have said it better.

We started with the 12-month proscuitto with ricotta served on grilled country bread. The breadsmith makes this bread exclusively for Bar Italia using the restaurant’s recipe. The crust is crunchy and the bread is soft and flavorful. Pace yourself. There’s a lot more to taste. The shrimp “aqua pazza” scampi is bathed in a spicy tomato sauce, topped with reggiano and more of that grilled country bread. I’m always up for sharing appetizers instead of ordering entrées, and I plan to go back and order the fritto misto, housemade meatballs, and Chef Rob’s stuffed peppers. Can’t wait.


For entrées, try one of the pasta dishes. Bar Italia makes their own pasta, and you really can’t go wrong with any of those dishes. If you want to try the pasta without committing to a large dish, try the one of the primo pasta smaller portions. The wood-fired pizza was impressive, with crispy crust and lots of toppings. Out of the six choices, we chose the Pig & Fig, with ripe figs, prosciutto, mozzarella, fig jam, and arugula. It was delicious, though a little on the sweet side. I could do with less jam, but that’s me. We still devoured the leftovers the next day.

Remember how I told you to pace yourself? I hope you do, because the desserts are fantastic. You’ll have quite a few choices, but just go with the caramelized cheesecake. It is so decadent. Pair it with a cappuccino or one of the coffee drinks. And speaking of drinks, Bar Italia has a nice wine list and quite a few craft cocktails. We plan to visit again soon to take advantage of the Happy Hour menu. See you there.

Find Bar Italia at 6568 University Parkway, Lakewood Ranch.


Scarpino’s Classic Italian

The only restaurant on this list located in west Bradenton, you’ll find Scarpino’s in Bayshore Shopping Center. Though this classic Italian restaurant was founded by Frank Scarpino over 30 years ago, it’s been given new life through new ownership and a renovation. Last year, the restaurant was purchased by Rob Arias. Though the decor has a whole new look, a couple of very important things haven’t changed. Many of the original recipes are still used, and much of the staff remains. Scarpino’s pizza chef, Giorgio, who relocated from Italy to work there, will continue to use his 25 years of experience to create those mouthwatering pizzas fans have loved for years.


With 16 appetizers to choose from, you might want to order a bottle of wine and try at least a couple. This is my kind of meal, where friends can share several starters like Scarpino’s shrimp or those tender meatballs, and not even get to the entrées. But then you’d miss the fettucine puttanesca and piccata.
Thinking pizza? You’ll have more than 25 to choose from. You might want to look at the menu ahead of time and decide before you go.

Don’t leave without dessert. Yes, you’ll have a dozen of those to choose from, too. Order the cheesecake and the cream puff cannoli. You’re welcome.

Visit Scarpino’s at 6152 14th St. W in Bradenton.

Old Friends Doing New Things

Though not new, some of our old favorites are making upgrades that feel like new. Harry’s Continental Kitchens on Longboat Key has been around since 1979, but with the recently added a covered patio, it feels like new.

Visit Harry’s Continental Kitchens at 5600 Gulf of Mexico Drive in Longboat Key.

Michael John’s has added a new bar, making it even easier to enjoy a casual meal on date night. We used to think of MJ’s as only fine dining, but have you tried their “filet mignon” burger with those crispy fries?

Find Michael John’s at 1040 Carlton Arms Boulevard in Bradenton.

Ed’s Tavern added a new location in east Bradenton. We had heard so many good things about it that we finally made it in on a rainy Saturday to a packed house. The menu is long and they have a full bar as well as local draft beer. The atmosphere is fun and family-friendly.

Ed’s is located at 1305 108th Street East in Bradenton.

Explore More Than One Local Spot on a Food Tour A great way to try several local restaurants is to go on a food tour. Key Culinary Tours has food tours in Anna Maria, Bradenton, Sarasota, and Venice. The tours typically go to four restaurants, ending with a sweet treat.

Scroll To Top